How fast should you reply to an enquiry? What the studies actually say

Reply within the hour, and sooner is better. The best known study, published in Harvard Business Review in 2011, found that firms which contacted a lead within an hour were about seven times more likely to have a meaningful conversation than firms that waited longer. The popular “21 times in 5 minutes” figure comes from a 2007 vendor presentation, not from MIT.
What did the Harvard Business Review study find?
In March 2011 James Oldroyd, Kristina McElheran and David Elkington published The Short Life of Online Sales Leads in Harvard Business Review. Looking at how more than 2,000 US companies handled web enquiries, they reported that most firms were not responding nearly fast enough.
The figures usually quoted from it: firms that tried to contact a lead within an hour were nearly seven times more likely to qualify it than firms that waited even an hour longer, and more than 60 times more likely than firms that waited 24 hours or more.
Two things are worth knowing before you quote it. The data is from the US and is now more than a decade old, and the article sits behind a paywall, so most people repeat the summary rather than the paper.
Where does “21 times more likely in 5 minutes” come from?
Not from MIT. It comes from a presentation by Dave Elkington, then chief executive of InsideSales.com, and James Oldroyd, who was at MIT at the time, given at a MarketingSherpa summit in October 2007. It used InsideSales’ own call data from six companies: more than 15,000 leads and over 100,000 call attempts.
The finding was that the odds of qualifying a lead were 21 times higher when the first call came within 5 minutes rather than 30. It is real data, but it is a vendor’s platform data about phone calls, presented at a conference rather than published in a journal. Treat it as a strong hint, not a law.
- 5 minutes21× the odds of qualifying a phone lead, compared with calling at 30 minutesInsideSales.com, 2007 (vendor data)
- 1 hourAbout 7× more likely to qualify the lead than replying an hour laterHarvard Business Review, 2011
- 229 business minutesWhat UK estate agents actually took, on average, to reply to a sales enquiryHomeflow mystery shop, 2023
- 4 hoursWhen 67% of home sellers expect a reply (26% expect one within the hour)YouGov for Zoopla, 2025
- 24 hours or moreOver 60× less likely to qualify than replying within the hourHarvard Business Review, 2011
How fast do businesses actually reply?
Slower than most owners think. In a 2023 mystery shop of UK estate agents, Homeflow found an average reply time of 229 business minutes to a sales enquiry, close to four working hours, and the slowest took more than four working days. Only half of the agents who replied did so within an hour.
| Fact | Source | Type |
|---|---|---|
| Contacting within an hour: about 7 times more likely to qualify the lead than an hour later, and 60 times more likely than after 24 hours | Harvard Business Review, March 2011 | Academic, US |
| Contact within 5 minutes: 21 times the odds of qualifying a phone lead compared with 30 minutes | InsideSales.com presentation, October 2007 | Vendor data |
| UK estate agents took 229 business minutes on average to reply to a sales enquiry | Homeflow mystery shop, September 2023 | Vendor study |
| 67% of home sellers expect a reply within 4 hours, 26% within an hour | YouGov for Zoopla, 1,000 sellers, November 2025 | Survey |
| 94.1% of weekday evening calls (6 to 9pm) to UK sales and lettings agents went unanswered | InStep AI, 3,047 numbers, May to July 2026 | Vendor study |
What do customers expect now?
A reply the same morning, not the same week. A YouGov survey of 1,000 home sellers for Zoopla in November 2025 found that 67% expect an agent to reply within four hours, and 26% within an hour.
What about enquiries that arrive after hours?
That is where most of the gap is. When InStep AI called 3,047 UK property business numbers on weekday evenings between May and July 2026, 94.1% of calls to sales and lettings agents between 6pm and 9pm went unanswered. InStep sells an AI answering service, so read it as a vendor study, but the pattern matches what owners tell us: enquiries keep arriving after the office closes, and nobody picks them up until the next day.
Do these numbers apply in the UAE?
Probably in direction, but nobody has published solid UAE data that we have found. Almost every response time study is from the US or the UK. That is one reason our audit includes one real test enquiry, with the owner’s permission: it measures your business, not an average.
What I’d do
- Measure before you fix. Send your own business a normal enquiry through each channel you advertise, on a weekday evening and on a weekend, and time the first reply and the follow up.
- Make the first reply useful, not just fast. “Thanks, we’ll be in touch” stops the clock in a report but not in the customer’s head. Answer the question or offer a clear next step.
- Give every enquiry an owner. Most slow replies are nobody’s job, not somebody being lazy.
- Cover the evening. If people enquire after 6pm, decide what happens to those enquiries before you spend more on ads.
If you want a second pair of eyes on it, request an audit. We time a real enquiry to your business and show you exactly where it slowed down.
You can see how the audit works and how it’s scored first, and what it looks like for Dubai real estate brokerages and clinics.
Questions people ask
Is the 5 minute rule real?
There is real data behind it: a 2007 InsideSales.com presentation found 21 times the odds of qualifying a phone lead when the first call came within 5 minutes instead of 30. It is vendor data from six companies, not an MIT study, so treat it as a strong hint rather than a law.
Does an automatic reply count as replying?
It tells the customer you received the enquiry, which helps. But the studies measured how quickly a business actually made contact. What moves the sale is a useful answer or a clear next step, from a person or from an AI that says it is an AI.
How fast do UK estate agents reply?
In Homeflow’s 2023 mystery shop the average was 229 business minutes to a sales enquiry, and only half of the agents who replied did so within an hour.
Is there response time data for the UAE?
We have not found a robust public study for the UAE. Most data is from the US and UK, which is why our audit measures a real enquiry to your own business, with your permission.
Sources (5), checked 25 October 2026
- Oldroyd, McElheran and Elkington, “The Short Life of Online Sales Leads”, Harvard Business Review, March 2011 (Paywalled; figures as widely quoted)
- Elkington and Oldroyd, Lead Response Management study, InsideSales.com, October 2007 (PDF copy) (Vendor data)
- Estate agents missing leads with slow response times, Estate Agent Today, September 2023 (Homeflow mystery shop) (Vendor study)
- Vendors expect estate agents to answer queries within an hour, The Negotiator (YouGov for Zoopla, November 2025)
- Agents miss 94% of evening calls, study finds, Property Industry Eye (InStep AI, 2026) (Vendor study)